Find a Comparison of ICICI Direct vs Shoonya by Finvasia here. You can compare their brokerage, demat accounts, trading platforms, offers, products & services, support, complaints & more.
This comparison will help you decide which broker is best for you. So, let us go through a detailed comparison of ICICI Direct and Shoonya by Finvasia.
| Year of Incorporation | 2000 | 2020 |
| Website | https://www.icicidirect.com/ | https://shoonya.com/ |
| Phone | 022 3355 1122 | +91-172-474-0000 |
| Exchanges enabled | NSE & BSE | BSE, NSE, NCDEX, MCX |
| Demat (NSDL/CDSL) | NSDL & CDSL | CDSL |
| Equity | 0.05% Equity Intraday | Zero in Delivery and 0.03% or Rs. 5, whichever is low in Intraday |
| Equity Futures | 0.05% or Rs 50 per Trade | 0.03% or Rs. 5, whichever is low |
| Equity Options | 0.05% or Rs 50 per Trade | Flat Rs. 5 + GST |
| Currency Futures | Rs 20 per executed order | 0.03% or Rs. 5, whichever is low |
| Currency Options | Rs 20 per executed order | Flat Rs. 5 + GST |
| Commodity | Rs 20 per executed order | 0.03% or Rs. 5 in Futures and Flat Rs. 5 + GST on Options |
| Trading only | Free | Free |
| Trading & Demat | Rs 975 for 3 in 1 Account | Free |
| Commodity | Rs 0 | Free |
Double check on if you are paying much higher other/turnover costs, make sure to compare
| Equity | 0.00325% of Turnover | 0 |
| Futures | 0.0019% of Turnover | 0 |
| Options | 0.05% of Turnover | 0 |
| Commodities | 0.05% of Turnover | 0 |
| AMC charge | Rs 700 per Year | 0 |
| DP Transaction Charge | Rs 25/Transaction or 0.05% whichever higher | Rs 9 + GST |
| Offline order placing Charge | 0 | 0 |
| Software |  |
|
| Web/HTML 5 | |
|
| Mobile | |
|
| Intraday | 20 Days | Yes |
| End of Day | 10 years | Yes |
| Coding/Backtesting |  |
|
| Online Trade Reports | |
|
| Online PNL Reports | |
|
| Online Contract Notes | |
|
Leverage Provided
| Equity | Upto 1x on Delivery & Upto 5x on Intraday | Upto 1x on Delivery & Upto 2x on Intraday |
| Equity Futures | Upto 4x | Upto 1x |
| Equity Options | Not for buying but upto 2x for shorting | Upto 1.5x |
| Currency Futures | 1x | Upto 1.2x |
| Currency Options | 1x | Upto 1.5x |
| Commodity | 1x | Upto 1.5x |
| Research & Tips | |
|
| Brokerage Calculator | |
|
| Margin Calculator | |
|
| Bracket orders & Trailing Stoploss | |
|
| Training & Education | |
|
| 3 in 1 Account | |
|
| Instant Fund withdrawal | |
|
| Relationship Managers | |
|
Equity & Commodity Consolidated
Look for Brokerages with higher profit, low debt, higher Profit to Equity Ratio which will indicate the profitability based on capital deployed, and atleast Rs 50 crores Balance sheet size. If a broker is in financial trouble, it will first start showing up on his balance sheet.
| Profit after Tax FY11/12 | Rs 77.1 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY12/13 | Rs 68.2 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY13/14 | Rs 94.9 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 14/15 | Rs 159.52 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 15/16 | Rs 196.88 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 16/17 | Rs 232.64 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 17/18 | Rs 300.80 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 18/19 | Rs 490.63 Crores | 0 |
| Profit after Tax FY 19/20 | Rs 539.16 Crores | Rs 140 Crores |
| Profit after Tax FY 20/21 | Rs 1,067.59 Crores | Rs 225.12 Crores |
| Profit after Tax FY 21/22 | Rs 1,383.82 Crores | Rs 248.93 Crores |
| Profit after Tax FY 22/23 | Rs 1,118.43 Crores | Rs 451.24 Crores |
| Debt FY11/12 | Rs 2,209 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY12/13 | Rs 4,219 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY13/14 | Rs 6,317 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY14/15 | Rs 8,250.83 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY15/16 | Rs 9,862.09 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY16/17 | Rs 10,435.99 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY17/18 | Rs 11,755.66 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY18/19 | Rs 12,859.36 Crores | 0 |
| Debt FY19/20 | Rs 13,689.28 Crores | Rs 5.31 Crores |
| Debt FY20/21 | Rs 14,536.48 Crores | Rs 6.45 Crores |
| Debt FY21/22 | Rs 15,798.99 Crores | Rs 7.63 Crores |
| Debt FY22/23 | Rs 15,882.15 Crores | Rs 6.85 Crores |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY11/12 | 32% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY12/13 | 21% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY13/14 | 27.07% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY14/15 | 29.22% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY15/16 | 30.63% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY16/17 | 32.89% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY17/18 | 41.55% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY18/19 | 40.19% | 0 |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY19/20 | 26.41% | 3.12% |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY20/21 | 33.02% | 2.75% |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY21/22 | 41.00% | 3.94% |
| Profit to Equity(%) FY22/23 | 40.45% | 4.31% |
| Balance Sheet Size FY11/12 | Rs 908 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY12/13 | Rs 948 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY13/14 | Rs 1620 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY14/15 | Rs 1857.26 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY15/16 | Rs 1903.86 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY16/17 | Rs 1983.64 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY17/18 | Rs 2,222.18 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY18/19 | Rs 2,350.41 Crores | 0 |
| Balance Sheet Size FY19/20 | Rs 5,470.58 Crores | Rs 1503 Crores |
| Balance Sheet Size FY20/21 | Rs 6,747.85 Crores | Rs 2314 Crores |
| Balance Sheet Size FY21/22 | Rs 8,921.25 Crores | Rs 3287.21 Crores |
| Balance Sheet Size FY22/23 | Rs 10,061.50 Crores | Rs 4821.39 Crores |
ICICI Direct Securities and Shoonya by Finvasia are both discount broker companies. Thus, to determine which is a better stockbroker, we need to examine details such as brokerage charges, account opening fees, trading platforms, and more.
Yes, both ICICI Direct Securities and Shoonya by Finvasia provide mobile trading apps for better user interface and seamless trading experience.
The account opening charges by brokers ICICI Direct and Shoonya by Finvasia for both trading and demat are zero. Charges may vary, kindly read the above comparison.
Both ICICI Direct and Shoonya by Finvasia are SEBI-registered brokers with good reputations. ICICI Direct is known for its trading platforms, while Shoonya by Finvasia is praised for cost-effective pricing.
Yes, both ICICI Direct and Shoonya by Finvasia offer margin trading facilities. However, terms, interest rates, and leverage limits vary, so reviewing their policies is essential.
